city versus country
July 12th, 2008So G & I thought we were ahead of the game by submitting an application for childcare at the Waldorf School a full 5 months ahead of time, but duh, no: they contacted us a few weeks ago to let us know they’d filled all (17? 18?) spaces for the fall and we were 26th on the waiting list. They regretted to say that it was pretty “unlikely” that we’d be able to get in.
On the one hand, I’m totally delighted that there’s so much support for the Waldorf here, and that there are parents out there excited about getting their kids into the program, since it means there must be (at least 30-35) moms in our immediate vicinity with toddlers Zen’s age who’re down with the arty Waldorf educational philosophy — potential friends!
On the other hand, damn them for getting there ahead of us, and who exactly are we competing against, here? Where are all these arty moms, are they actually here in Pittsburgh? Can I meet them? Do they push unaffordable strollers and obsess about cleanliness and are they trend-conscious in their interest in Waldorf, or are they actually real people who eat meat and dress their kids in hand-me-downs and take public transit?
More specifically, do they say they live in Pittsburgh but actually live in places like Mount Lebanon and Fox Chapel? Because that’s just not cool.
This post is a rant but it’s not anything to do with the Waldorf — really it’s to do with this aggravating trend in which young professionals looking to start a family avoid the City of Pittsburgh like the plague, talk trash about its horrendous public schools and crumbling infrastructure, but of course all the while they all work in the city and commute in by car every day, shop at Whole Foods and visit museums and theaters and sports events and so forth, availing themselves of culture and city services they never have to pay for. And of course if you ask them they all say they’re from Pittsburgh.
Take the well-intentioned www.pittsburghmom.com, which appears to be a site where Pittsburgh mothers can connect with each other to consult about local playgrounds and schools and daycare and family-friendly restaurants, etc., maybe set up playgroups and make new friends (which is why I just signed up — I’m looking for all those things). Check out the discussion boards, though, and it seems like 99% of the people using the site live in the suburbs. One post from a woman looking for information about Pittsburgh in advance of a possible future move here from Ohio asked for recommendations about neighborhoods and schools and so forth — and not a single one of the replies even deigned to consider what’s available in the city. Have you looked at Fox Chapel and the Avonworth schools? We love it here in Mount Lebanon and Cranberry. There’s so much available in the Monroeveille/Plum area. Meanwhile I’m all, but if you’re going to be working at UPMC, why not live in Oakland? or Squirrel Hill or Shadyside, if Oakland is too declassé for you. Is this for real? Where are all the Pittsburgh moms, exactly?
I’m looking ahead to the fall when I’m planning to stop working for a little bit in order to Mom full-time, and getting nervous. It feels like a little bit of a luxury to be able to stay home, after all — we’re able to squeak by on G’s income, and we don’t have to hustle like we did in New York just to make rent, so as far as we’re concerned we’re rich, and this staying-at-home plan is something of an indulgence. In theory, at least, we’d be even better off if I worked full time, right? But in reality I’m beginning to doubt that.
I learned from experience in New York that the more you work, and the better paid you are for that work, the more money you spend, and the less time you actually have to yourself. Within an order of magnitude, the marginal return on a pay increase is a fraction of the actual difference in pay level. You spend more time at work, and when you’re done you don’t have a lot of mental energy to do stuff like housework and errands and body maintenance and other chores, let alone spend quality time with your family and fun stuff like cultural events, etc., so you buy things and contract for services in an effort to make your life more enjoyable or convenient or efficient. Life gets more expensive.
Here in Pittsburgh it’s maybe even more the case — because the payscales for the non-profit work that I do are pretty low, and the difference between what I make per hour and what we pay our babysitter, for example, isn’t a whole lot. I could work more, but I’d have to pay for full-time childcare and probably also a housekeeper (to avoid going completely insane); and then I’d also have much less time to bargain-hunt when shopping for food or clothing or other necessities; not to mention the fact that I’d have very little time to interact with G given his chaotic round-the-clock schedule; and of course I’d be doing all this while giving someone else the privilege of playing with my baby. It really doesn’t seem worth it, and ironically I feel like I’d actually be able to save money by not working at all.
But I don’t want to deprive Zen of the company of kids his own age, even if I’m able to give him much more of my attention — which brings me back to whole issue of signing up for daycare and looking for playgroups and moms of toddlers Zen’s age, and the mysteries of being a mom in Pittsburgh. Like many cities, Pittsburgh has many excellent daycare programs that are all over-subscribed, with long waiting lists; but unlike many other cities, Pittsburgh doesn’t actually have many kids. Enrollment in the public and parochial schools is declining drastically, and there’s a big demographic hole where the 25-to-40-year-olds are supposed to be, here.
Which leads me to be very suspicious about the fact that we’re 26th on the waiting list at the Waldorf. If there are that many kindred-spirit moms in Pittsburgh, how come I don’t know any of them? Am I totally out of touch? I can’t help but think we’re competing with families from the snazzy suburbs who’re up on the Reggio Emilia trend, here. Makes me want to stalk the pick-up lines for the Little Friends program this fall, just to see how many kids are being fetched in SUVs with suburban stickers. Grrrrr.
I could be totally wrong, of course. I’d be happy to be wrong. Maybe this fall I’ll have the time to sleuth out the hidden meet-ups of 30-something really-from-Pittsburgh moms with second-hand strollers and good recipies for kale and butternut squash, and I’ll cheerfully print a retraction to this rant. But until then…
It seems to me in comparison with other kids he’s a quiet little guy, and he smiles a lot at adults, looking for smiles back. It’s hard for me to judge, because we don’t know that many one-year-olds, but the few we’ve played with have mostly been more active and vocal than Z, or so it’s seemed to me. Very hard to tell. I need to get this kid some playmates, sigh. He spends too much time with me and G individually, and only children that we are we’re not always aware of how little we’re actually speaking when we’re playing with him, since he doesn’t talk. We’re both so accustomed to playing silently by ourselves, and we’re inadvertantly raising our kid to do the same.